LawsOf Robots

Frequently asked questions

Where can I download and install RES or RQR for a Raspberry Pi?

A self-service RES/RQR runtime installer and general supported Raspberry Pi installation path are not currently available. Controlled Pi packages are not a general customer installer. Read Software & setup for current availability and help. Payment and robot records do not install software; GRRC certification is optional for normal RES/RQR use.

Questions about the complete Laws Of Robots System, RES governance, public evidence, privacy, and present availability — answered from the published record.

Each answer summarizes a current public source. Follow the source link for the authoritative wording. Where the public record does not support an answer, this page says so rather than filling the gap with a promise.

Choose your starting point

The same public record can answer different first questions. Choose the path closest to yours; each leads to the published sources behind the answer.

Owner control and everyday use

These answers explain the journey and its boundaries. Private account and robot information stays in the responsible application.

Who does the robot answer to?

Its obedience is owed to its Owner within the published Laws. The Owner can delegate authority under those Laws. A maker, service provider or certifier does not gain command authority merely by supplying its service.

The Owner journey · Read the Privacy Commitments

Is a robot record the same as an installed robot?

No. A record identifies the robot in the Owner's Estate. Installation, compatibility, startup and ordinary operation require their own supported workflow. Pairing and a certificate do not install software.

The Owner journey · Read the Privacy Commitments

Are curriculum and service rights the same thing?

No. Curriculum is signed governing content. Service rights come from a defined offering and its terms. Payment does not create task authority, establish compatibility or grant GRRC certification.

The Owner journey · Read the Privacy Commitments

Must my robot be certified to use RES or RQR?

No. Certification is optional for normal operation. Its bounded result can support a relying party's trust decision, but it does not replace the Owner's authority or prove that every decision, observation or message is correct.

The Owner journey · Read the Privacy Commitments

Does a decision record preserve every private detail forever?

The Privacy Commitments distinguish readable personal content from verifiable record structure. WP06 explains the conditions for completed erasure and the limits concerning other copies, prior exports and the Owner-held identity link. A retained envelope is not a readable reconstruction of erased meaning.

The Owner journey · Read the Privacy Commitments

What does privacy over a robot's lifetime mean?

Privacy remains a requirement through use, updates, servicing, recovery, transfer and retirement. The actual service should explain retention, access and external processing at each stage. This purpose does not claim that every future migration or recovery path has already been qualified.

The Owner journey · Read the Privacy Commitments

Can Karel inspect my account or recover it for me?

No. Karel explains approved public information. Use the RES Owner application for private account or robot matters and its recovery guidance for access problems. Do not enter passkeys, recovery links, signing material or private records into Karel.

The Owner journey · Read the Privacy Commitments

Start here

The basic model: what RES is, why it exists, and what it does not claim.

What is the Robot Expert System?

The Robot Expert System, or RES, is described as a trust-and-record layer inside an autonomous system. It applies an ordered safety floor and the Owner's additional rules, then leaves a tamper-evident record of its decision.

Source: Getting Started, About

What problem is RES intended to address?

RES is intended to make a robot's governed decisions understandable and checkable after the fact. It does not present itself as a way to make a robot faster, more capable, or wiser.

Source: Getting Started, About

Is RES ordinary robot software or a manufacturer's AI feature?

No. The public description places RES alongside a robot's capability stack as a trust-and-record layer: it governs decisions and records them rather than serving as the robot's general autonomy, planning, or capability software.

Source: Getting Started, About

Who decides what the robot is allowed to do?

The public model describes fixed Laws as the safety floor. An Owner may add rules above that floor to make them stricter, but no party may lower the floor.

Source: Getting Started, The Laws

Why should someone who does not own a robot care?

The public case is about trust: as autonomous systems act around people, the important question is not only what they can do, but whether the basis for a decision can later be checked independently.

Source: Home, WP01 — Trust Will Decide the Robot Age — Not Capability

Is RES an AI language model that decides what a robot should do?

No such claim is made. The published description presents RES as a rule-bound governance and record layer. Karel is the separate public website helper and only answers from approved public LOR information.

Source: Getting Started, About, Ask Karel

What does RES not claim to do?

RES does not claim to make a robot generally safe, guarantee wise decisions, replace all robot software, or turn a certificate into a safety certification. The Status and Proof pages set the limits of those claims.

Source: Proof, Status, About

Owner control and availability

What an Owner can tighten, what no one can lower, and what is actually available today.

Can an Owner lower the safety floor?

No. An Owner may add protections or make rules stricter, but the public description says the ordered safety floor cannot be lowered by the Owner, a maker, or another party.

Source: Getting Started, The Laws, Home

Can an Owner tighten the rules?

Yes. The Owner's rules sit above the fixed floor and may make the applicable limits stricter. They do not provide a way to bypass a refusal below the floor.

Source: Getting Started, The Laws

Does RES need a permanent internet connection to make a judgment?

No. The public design says judgment runs inside the machine, and no network is required to decide.

Source: Getting Started, Proof

What happens if the network is disconnected?

The public design says the record remains verifiable offline. Disconnecting the machine from a network does not make verification depend on a server, dashboard, or the operator's word.

Source: Proof, Security

Is RES available to buy or install today?

The Status page is the authoritative current answer. It describes RES as at early product maturity and in owner use; it does not claim a shipped robot or third-party deployment.

Source: Status

How do I become an Owner?

Use Create Owner account in the RES Owner application. Verify your email, set up a device-verified passkey and explicitly sign in. Then pay the USD 10 one-time Owner fee; after that, enter robot details and pay the USD 1 new-robot fee. Return to the LOR application and choose Complete robot addition to create the robot record. An unpaid Owner can sign in and resume Billing. Payment, software installation and separate GRRC certification are distinct. Signup, its policy pages and Billing currently use English.

Create Owner account · Existing Owner sign-in

Source: Owners, Getting Started, Status

Does an Owner account give Karel access to robot information?

No. Karel's public interface states that it uses approved public website information and cannot access Owner accounts or Robot data.

Source: Ask Karel, Privacy policy

New to robot ownership

A public learning path for people asking “What do I do now?” It is information, not account setup or robot pairing.

I am new to this. Where should I start?

Start with Getting Started to understand what RES is and is not. Then read The Laws for the fixed safety floor, Proof for what can be checked after a decision, and Privacy Commitments for the treatment of Owner and bystander information. Finally, check Status for the product's current maturity and availability.

Source: Getting Started, The Laws, Proof, Privacy Commitments, Status

Can I create an Owner account now?

Yes. Use Create Owner account to verify your email and set up a device-verified passkey, then sign in explicitly. Account creation is separate from the USD 10 one-time Owner fee. An unpaid Owner can sign in and resume Billing. After Owner payment, enter robot details, pay the USD 1 new-robot fee, then return to the LOR application and choose Complete robot addition. Signup, its policy pages and Billing currently use English.

Create Owner account · Existing Owner sign-in

Source: Owners, Status

Will reading these pages register me or pair a robot with RES?

No. The public reading path is educational only. It does not create an Owner account, establish eligibility, pair a robot, or change a robot's behavior.

Source: Owners, Getting Started, Status

I already own a robot. Can I add RES to it today?

The public site does not make a compatibility, installation, or commercial availability claim for a particular robot. Check Status for the current product boundary rather than assuming that an existing robot can be converted or paired.

Source: Status

What will the real Owner onboarding guide cover when it is available?

The public site provides product reading through Getting Started, FAQ, Status, and Privacy Commitments. Account setup, account recovery, robot pairing, initial configuration, support, eligibility, pricing, and Owner data handling are controlled by the RES registration and Owner UI.

Source: Owners, Status

Decisions, records, and verification

What the public record says can be checked after a governed decision — and the limits of that check.

How does a governed decision happen?

At a public-description level, an instruction is evaluated against the Laws and the Owner's additional rules. The robot acts or refuses, records the decision and reason, and the record can later be checked.

Source: Getting Started, The Laws

What is a decision record?

The public sources describe it as the tamper-evident, append-only record of the machine's decisions. It is intended to travel with the agent rather than depend on a remote dashboard.

Source: Proof, Privacy Commitments

How is an RES decision record different from an ordinary robot log?

The public record describes an RES decision record as a tamper-evident, append-only record of the machine's decisions and their stated reasons. It is designed to be verified offline and to support re-derivation of a recorded decision. Laws Of Robots does not describe or assess the contents, reliability, or retention practices of another robot's logs.

Source: Proof, Getting Started

What does verification prove?

Verification reports the bounded things the record can support: that the record is intact and that a decision can be re-derived and checked.

Source: Proof

What does verification not prove?

It does not certify that a decision was wise, that the robot is generally safe, or more than the record can establish.

Source: Proof, Status

Can the record be silently altered after the fact?

The claim is not that any system is unhackable. The narrower public claim is that an alteration to the record is intended to be detectable as a broken verification chain rather than silently accepted as genuine.

Source: Home, Proof, Security

What can an independent reviewer check after a decision?

A reviewer can check what the public verification process is designed to support: whether the record is intact and whether the decision can be re-derived and checked. The process is designed not to depend on a manufacturer server, a dashboard, or a party's say-so. It does not certify that the decision was wise, and it does not state more than the record can carry.

Source: Proof, Security

Does the original robot have to be online for verification?

The public design says the record travels with the agent and verifies offline. Specific reviewer tooling or procedures are only described where the public Proof material says they are available.

Source: Proof

Does a GRRC certificate say that a robot is safe?

No. The public site does not present the RES certificate as certification of a robot, the complete Laws Of Robots System, or general safety. The registry and Status page define the narrower claim that can actually be checked.

Source: Status

Privacy, household information, and Karel

How the published commitments describe bystanders, website data, and Karel’s public-information boundary.

What happens to data about visitors, children, or neighbors?

The Privacy Commitments define a bystander as someone the machine perceives who is not the Owner. The public commitment says bystander information has no passive or automatic route into the record; admission requires an explicit, attributed act and a reason for accountability.

Source: Privacy Commitments

Are privacy and accountability opposed to one another?

The public Privacy Commitments present them as complements:

A person's information can be destroyed on request, but the tamper-evident record of what the machine did cannot be altered or erased by anyone, including the owner.

Source: Privacy Commitments

What information does the website collect?

The Privacy Policy is the source of record for this website. It explains the site's use of same-site assets and its no-advertising/no-third-party-analytics posture, alongside the separate treatment of a message sent to a published contact address.

Source: Privacy policy

Are Karel questions and answers stored by this site?

No. The current Privacy Policy states that the application does not add content logging of Karel questions or answers, and that its model request is configured as stateless. Standard Azure service and security logs may still be kept under Microsoft's terms.

Source: Privacy policy

What can Karel use to answer a question?

Karel uses an approved public LOR corpus and links the public sources behind its response. The linked source, rather than Karel's wording, remains the authoritative wording.

Source: Ask Karel, Privacy policy

What should I not enter into Karel?

Do not enter personal, confidential, Owner, or Robot information. Karel is not a legal adviser, certifier, emergency service, or a source for safety-critical decisions.

Source: Ask Karel, Privacy policy

GRRC, independence, and current maturity

Who is separate from whom, what can be checked today, and what the Status page does not claim.

What is GRRC's role?

GRRC is the external certifier for the published RES certification. It remains outside the Laws Of Robots product chain; its role does not make it the certifier of RQR, Robot Integration, Scenario Lab, Extensibility, or the complete System.

Source: Home, About, Proof

Can a maker, Owner, or robot certify itself?

Not for the RES certificate described here. The public sources say that certification is issued by GRRC, not by the maker, Owner, robot, or Laws Of Robots operator. The stated purpose is to prevent self-certification from being treated as independent assurance.

Source: Home, Proof, About

What is independently checkable today?

The public pages describe the RES certificate in GRRC's registry and offline verification of an RES decision record. They also publish component-level Status so readers can distinguish current RES claims from work that is in development or planned.

Source: Home, Proof, Status

Is this a deployed third-party or fleet product today?

No such claim is made. The Status page says there is one operator and no third-party use is claimed.

Source: Status

Technical and professional readers

The public architecture boundary for engineers, evaluators, risk readers, and anyone asking what RES does not replace.

Does RES replace a robot's autonomy or planning stack?

No. RES is described as the layer that governs and records decisions from the robot's capability stack. It is not positioned as a general replacement for the robot's autonomy, planning, or capability software.

Source: Getting Started, About

How are the Laws and Owner rules related?

The Laws form the ordered safety floor. Owner rules are additional constraints above that floor and may tighten it; they do not lower or reorder it.

Source: Getting Started, The Laws

What does an independent reviewer receive?

The public materials describe an offline-verifiable record and a bounded verification result. They do not promise a proprietary interface, API, service-level agreement, or a particular reviewer workflow.

Source: Proof, Status

Does RES make a risk, insurance, or liability promise?

No. The public pages describe auditable reasoning and record integrity. They do not claim a premium reduction, a particular legal result, lower incident probability, or a general finding of insurability.

Source: Proof, Status, WP01 — Trust Will Decide the Robot Age — Not Capability

Where can a reader learn the larger trust argument?

WP01, Trust Will Decide the Robot Age — Not Capability, is the public starting paper. It frames trust—not capability—as the gating issue and points to why the party that needs to be trusted cannot simply certify itself.

Source: WP01 — Trust Will Decide the Robot Age — Not Capability, Papers

The complete Laws Of Robots System

How governance, cognition and coordination, robot integration, and proving tools fit together without sharing authority.

What are the main parts of the Laws Of Robots System?

The public architecture separates RES governance, RQR, and Robot Integration. Scenario Lab now provides a deterministic public replay of those boundaries, while Extensibility describes future specialist modules. Each part has a named job and an explicit authority boundary.

Source: System Overview

Can RQR authorize robot work?

No. It may maintain evidence-based beliefs, expose uncertainty, and prepare or coordinate candidate work, but RES alone determines permission and obligation. RQR enriches RES; it never becomes a second governance engine or a prerequisite for RES to continue governing.

Source: System Overview, RES — Governance, RQR

Is Robot Integration another governing product?

No. Robot Integration is the adapter boundary to sensors, navigation, drivers, middleware, simulation, and eventual physical actuation. It carries authorized goals and returns evidence; it does not decide whether consequential work is permitted.

Source: System Overview, Robot Integration

Is Scenario Lab a live robot or open development system?

No. The public Scenario Lab is a curated, deterministic replay using named TRES and RobotSim versions and conditions. It does not expose unrestricted scenario submission, a live development system, or physical actuation.

Source: Scenario Lab, Status

This FAQ is a guide to public information. It does not create an Owner account, pair a robot, give legal or safety advice, or replace the published Status, Proof, Privacy Commitments, or Laws pages.